

A car accident claim is not decided by how bad the crash looked. It comes down to paperwork and deadlines. It also comes down to how hard the insurance company pushes back once you file. You need to know what your claim is worth before you agree to anything, and you need that answer from someone other than the insurer writing the check.
As a New Haven car accident lawyer, Frank Bartlett has built his career representing injured clients, and he has seen firsthand how insurance companies try to pay less. His firm, Bartlett & Grippe, LLC, has recovered more than $50 million for injured clients across Connecticut since 2012, including a $200,000 settlement for a driver rear-ended on I-91 whose insurer tried to use her old back injury and light bumper damage as a reason to pay less. Results like these depend on the facts of each case, not a promise for how yours will turn out.
Frank builds your case the same way, starting with the same question every adjuster hopes you never ask: what this claim is worth. The goal is a case built strong enough that the insurance company can’t easily talk you down.
Tell us what happened. Tell us what the insurance company has offered so far. We’ll give you a straight answer on whether it’s enough.
| Best Law Firms® 2026 – Personal Injury Litigation | 60+ Years Combined Experience | $50M+ Recovered Since 2012 | Best Lawyers® 2026 Edition |
Any car accident can potentially be life-changing for those involved. Whether you or a family member is hurt in an accident, the first steps you take in the aftermath will directly influence your recovery.
Bartlett & Grippe represents injured drivers, passengers, and families across New Haven.
The crash may look different from case to case, but the insurance question is almost always the same: what is fair, and how do you make sure you get it.
Here is what we handle most often:
The plaintiff was rear-ended on Interstate 91. Attorney Bartlett secured a $200,000 settlement despite prior back injuries and minimal property damage.
A woman struck from behind on the Merritt Parkway received a $70,000 verdict after the insurer refused a reasonable offer.
An adjuster’s job is to protect the insurer’s money, not yours.
In a New Haven car accident claim, that usually shows up in a few ways:
What percentage of fault would you accept for a crash you did not cause?
A lawyer answers that question for the insurer instead of you, and that changes what they are willing to pay.
These are real settlements and verdicts from our case files, not estimates or averages.
Past results do not guarantee the same outcome in your case, since every crash and every insurer’s file are different, but they show what happens when we push back instead of accepting the first number offered.
| Outcome | Case Type |
| $200,000 Settlement | Rear-end crash on I-91, New Haven-area driver, despite a prior back injury and minor property damage (Donna M. v. Siemens) |
| $70,000 Verdict | Rear-end crash in stop-and-go traffic on the Merritt Parkway, after the insurer refused a reasonable offer |
We have recovered more than $50 million for injured clients across Connecticut since 2012. That includes a $200,000 settlement for a rear-end crash victim and a $70,000 verdict after an insurer refused a fair offer.
Attorney Frank Bartlett is recognized in Best Lawyers for Personal Injury Litigation, and our firm carries a Best Law Firms ranking in the same category.
Call us and we will tell you plainly where your case stands against that record.
We work on contingency, so you pay no attorney’s fees unless we recover money for you. Our fee comes out of the settlement or verdict itself. We will explain exactly how that works before you sign anything.
You’re free to accept it on your own, but it’s worth having a lawyer look at it first. Early offers are usually calculated before your treatment is finished. They often come in before anyone adds up your lost wages or future care. Once you sign a release, you cannot go back and ask for more. That is true even if your injury turns out worse than it first looked. Call us before you sign anything, not after.
Connecticut law gives you two years to file a lawsuit. That two years usually starts on the date you were injured, but if the injury wasn’t obvious right away, the clock can start later, on the date you discovered it, or the date you reasonably should have discovered it. You get no more than three years from the date of the crash itself, under Conn. Gen. Stat. Section 52-584. This reflects Connecticut law as of August 2026. That deadline comes faster than most people expect once treatment, insurance back and forth, and daily life eat up the calendar.
That claim gets made often, and it does not end your case. Under Connecticut’s modified comparative negligence rule, you can still recover as long as you are found less than 51 percent at fault. Your compensation gets reduced by your share of the fault, so the size of that share is worth fighting over. We build the evidence that keeps your share as low as the facts support.
Most New Haven car accident lawsuits are filed at the New Haven Superior Court at 235 Church Street. We have handled cases there for years. We know how the judges and clerks in that courthouse expect a case to be presented, and what tends to move a case forward instead of stalling it.
If your question is not listed here, ask us directly when you call.

Once you sign a release or cash a check, your case is generally over. That is true whether or not it covers everything you lost. Before that happens, tell us what happened and what the insurance company has offered.
We will tell you plainly whether it reflects what your claim is worth, and if it does not, we will build the case to get you there.
Contact Bartlett & Grippe, LLC today to schedule a free consultation.